Fleet Wire

Aviation Fleet Strategy & News

Regional Airlines Face a $6 Million Engine Cost Challenge

Regional Airlines Face Rising Maintenance Cost Pressures

Regional airlines are confronting a growing challenge that threatens to reshape their fleet strategies: the rising cost of keeping aircraft in service. From expensive engine overhauls to shortages of critical components, maintenance has become an increasingly difficult expense to manage, putting pressure on operators already working with tight margins.

Emerald Airlines CEO Keith Butler has described escalating maintenance costs as a fundamental challenge to the regional airline business model. Speaking at the European Regions Airline Association (ERAA) general assembly in Belfast, Butler warned that maintenance inflation is accelerating at a rate that could become unsustainable for regional carriers.

His concerns reflect a broader problem across the sector. Airlines are not simply paying more for repairs and replacement components. They are also struggling to secure parts, extend the service life of older aircraft, and make fleet investment decisions when engine maintenance timelines remain uncertain.

For regional operators, which often depend on smaller aircraft and operate routes with limited revenue potential, the consequences can be particularly severe. A prolonged maintenance visit or an unexpectedly expensive overhaul can affect aircraft availability, operating schedules, and the financial case for keeping a fleet in service.

Maintenance Inflation Is Testing the Regional Airline Model

Butler told delegates that maintenance costs are rising at two to three times the rate of general inflation, making them increasingly difficult for airlines to absorb.

“Maintenance costs are becoming such a high percentage of the cost base, but more importantly are accelerating at a greater rate than a lot of the other costs,” he said.

The concern is not just the absolute amount airlines spend on maintenance. It is the speed at which those expenses are increasing compared with other operating costs.

Regional airlines typically have fewer opportunities than larger network carriers to spread unexpected expenses across extensive route networks. Their business models can also be more exposed to fluctuations in demand, aircraft utilisation, and the economics of individual routes.

When maintenance bills rise faster than revenue, operators may find it harder to justify keeping older aircraft in service. Yet replacing those aircraft is not necessarily an easy solution, particularly when new aircraft deliveries, engine availability, and maintenance capacity remain important considerations.

Butler’s warning points to a difficult balance for regional airlines: they need reliable aircraft to sustain their operations, but the cost of maintaining those aircraft is becoming a growing financial burden.

Engine Overhauls Can Cost More Than Older Aircraft Are Worth

The scale of the problem was evident in comments from SAS Group Vice President for Airline Operations and External Production Mikael Wangdahl.

Wangdahl highlighted the difficulties associated with sourcing engines, landing gear, and other components for regional aircraft, particularly variants that are no longer in production.

As fleets age and manufacturers discontinue older models or variants, operators can become increasingly dependent on limited supplies of serviceable components. Airlines may need to invest heavily in equipment that has already depreciated significantly in market value.

Wangdahl cited the example of a Bombardier CRJ aircraft requiring an engine overhaul costing approximately $6 million, despite the aircraft having no remaining hull value.

“You have to invest a lot in old equipment to get them to continue operating,” he said.

The example illustrates a difficult calculation for fleet planners. An aircraft may have little residual value, but its engines and other components can still represent substantial maintenance liabilities.

Retiring the aircraft could mean losing useful capacity and potentially facing the cost of replacement. Keeping it in service, however, may require an investment that is difficult to justify against the aircraft’s remaining earning potential.

These decisions become even more complicated when airlines cannot be certain how long an engine overhaul will take or whether replacement components will be available when required.

Pratt & Whitney Canada Engine Delays Complicate Planning

Engine maintenance delays are adding another layer of uncertainty for regional operators.

Wangdahl said lead times for Pratt & Whitney Canada PW127 engine maintenance associated with ATR aircraft had increased from approximately 90 days to between 250 and 300 days.

That represents a substantial extension of the period an airline may have to plan around when an engine requires maintenance.

For an operator with a relatively small fleet, losing an aircraft or engine for several months can create operational complications. Spare capacity may be limited, while leasing replacement equipment or rearranging schedules can introduce additional costs.

The uncertainty also affects decisions about fleet renewal.

SAS began examining Embraer’s E2 aircraft in 2019 but did not proceed with its order until 2025. Wangdahl said engine maintenance concerns contributed to the delay in the decision.

The example demonstrates how aftermarket support can influence aircraft purchasing decisions well beyond the initial acquisition price.

Airlines evaluating a new aircraft type must consider not only fuel efficiency, passenger capacity, and acquisition costs, but also the availability of spare engines, maintenance infrastructure, and long-term support.

An aircraft that performs well operationally may still present a difficult investment proposition if its engines cannot be maintained within a predictable timeframe.

Spare-Parts Shortages Are Forcing Airlines to Rethink Supply Chains

The difficulties extend beyond engine maintenance.

Wangdahl said one airline, whose identity was not disclosed, had begun stockpiling as many spare parts as possible to protect its fleet and operations.

“You really have to be your own supply chain,” he said.

The comment highlights a significant change in how regional airlines may need to approach inventory management.

Under more predictable conditions, operators can order replacement components when required rather than holding large quantities of stock. That approach helps limit the amount of capital tied up in inventory.

However, when parts are difficult to source, waiting for a component can leave an aircraft unavailable for service. Airlines may then face additional costs associated with disrupted schedules, aircraft substitutions, and maintenance delays.

Building up spare-parts inventories can reduce that exposure, but it creates its own financial challenges. Components sitting in storage represent capital that cannot be used elsewhere, and operators must determine which parts are most critical to their fleets.

The problem is particularly acute for older aircraft variants, where the availability of replacement components can become less predictable as the installed fleet shrinks.

For regional airlines, maintaining access to engines and critical parts is increasingly becoming a strategic consideration rather than a routine procurement task.

KLM Cityhopper Turns to Older Aircraft for Protection

KLM Cityhopper has also encountered difficulties securing components, including carbon brakes, according to managing director Maarten Koopmans.

Koopmans described a situation in which maintenance teams were spending considerable time trying to locate parts that airlines would traditionally expect to order through established supply channels.

“If I talk to my maintenance people, every day they are trying to find parts. Normally you would just order parts, right? Now it’s a struggle day after day, and it’s scattered around the portfolio,” he said.

The airline has also faced engine-related challenges affecting its Embraer E195-E2 fleet.

During the early stages of Pratt & Whitney’s powder metal-related engine problems, Koopmans feared KLM Cityhopper might have to ground as many as 12 of its 25 E195-E2 aircraft.

Ultimately, the airline parked four aircraft and covered them completely in protective white plastic while they were out of service.

Koopmans said all four aircraft had since been brought back into the maintenance process. Three had returned to flying, while the fourth was undergoing maintenance at the time of his comments.

He also acknowledged improvements in the supply chain supporting Pratt & Whitney’s own maintenance operations, suggesting that conditions had become more manageable than during the earlier disruption.

Nevertheless, the experience illustrates how engine-related maintenance problems can threaten the availability of a significant portion of a regional carrier’s fleet.

Why KLM Cityhopper Is Keeping Its Older Embraers

KLM Cityhopper’s response also demonstrates why airlines may be reluctant to retire older aircraft when newer fleets face maintenance uncertainty.

Koopmans said the airline was keeping its first-generation Embraer E-Jets in service for longer as backup aircraft.

He added that the carrier might even begin dismantling some of the older aircraft to recover parts.

Keeping older aircraft available can give airlines additional flexibility when newer models require maintenance or when components become difficult to obtain. Retired aircraft can also serve as sources of used serviceable material, helping operators support aircraft that remain in active service.

However, this approach is not without limitations. Components must be suitable for the aircraft being maintained, and recovered parts must meet the applicable technical and regulatory requirements. Dismantling aircraft also involves costs, meaning the economics depend on the value and usability of the components recovered.

Even so, the strategy reflects the growing importance of spare-parts access in fleet planning.

For airlines facing long engine turnaround times and component shortages, an older aircraft can retain operational value beyond its ability to generate revenue through scheduled passenger services.

Maintenance Costs Could Influence Future Fleet Decisions

The concerns raised at the ERAA general assembly suggest that maintenance economics will play an increasingly important role in regional aviation.

Airlines must decide how long to retain older aircraft, how much to invest in engines with limited remaining economic value, and whether newer aircraft offer sufficient operational advantages to justify the transition.

The answers will vary by fleet and operator. However, the experiences shared by Emerald Airlines, SAS, and KLM Cityhopper point to a common challenge: the cost and availability of aftermarket support can influence an aircraft’s commercial value just as significantly as its operating performance.

Engine manufacturers and maintenance providers will therefore remain central to the sector’s ability to manage the problem. More predictable turnaround times, improved component availability, and greater access to serviceable parts could help airlines plan their operations and capital spending with greater confidence.

For now, regional carriers face a difficult combination of rising maintenance expenses and uncertainty over when essential components will become available.

Butler’s warning that the industry is approaching a breaking point underscores the stakes. If maintenance costs continue to rise faster than other expenses, airlines may have to reconsider fleet utilisation, aircraft retirement timelines, and the economics of serving regional markets.

The challenge is no longer simply about keeping aircraft airworthy. It is about ensuring that the cost of doing so remains compatible with the business model that makes regional air connectivity possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *